Is Your Website Killing Your Sales? 10 Signs You Need a Website Redesign

Modern website redesign concept for small businesses in Lehigh Valley

Your website isn’t just a digital business card—it’s your 24/7 salesperson. It greets every visitor, answers questions, builds trust, and guides people toward a yes.

But if the experience feels slow, confusing, or outdated, your website isn’t just underperforming… it’s quietly costing you real revenue.

In fact:

  • 81% of people think less of a brand if a website looks outdated
  • 39% reconsider buying if a site isn’t user-friendly
  • Companies that invest in a strategic website redesign often see 10–20% revenue growth within the first year

If you’re a small business in Bethlehem, Allentown, Easton, or anywhere in the Lehigh Valley, this breakdown will help you diagnose the problem—and know exactly when it’s time to initiate a website redesign.


1. Your Bounce Rate Is Sky-High (Major Website Design Red Flag)

If visitors land on your website and instantly leave, your analytics are waving a red flag.

Common causes include:

  • Slow load times
  • Confusing design
  • Unclear messaging
  • Poor mobile experience

Check your analytics and test your speed with PageSpeed Insights.

A bounce is a “no thanks.” Too many of them means your website is turning customers away.

Analytics showing high bounce rate on small business website

2. Traffic, Leads, and Sales Are Dropping

A steady decline in visits, form submissions, or sales is rarely random.

It often means your:

  • Messaging no longer matches customer expectations
  • User experience is outdated
  • Funnel has friction
  • Search visibility has dropped

If you’re seeing a downward trend, it’s time to review your entire digital experience. Need support? Explore our website design services.


3. Your Website Loads Slowly (Performance Issues)

Slow equals gone.

If your site takes more than 2–3 seconds to load, users bounce and Google lowers your ranking.

Use:

For deeper fixes, read our full guide on website speed optimization.


4. Your Mobile Experience Is Bad (Responsive Design Failure)

Most Lehigh Valley shoppers browse on their phones. If your site forces people to pinch, zoom, or guess where to tap, they’re gone.

Mobile-friendly website example for Bethlehem small businesses

A professional website redesign ensures users on iPhone and Android have a smooth, frictionless experience.


5. Navigation Is Confusing

Great navigation feels invisible. If people get lost or can’t find key pages, your structure needs a redesign.

Clear UX = more conversions.
Cluttered UX = lost sales.

Review usability best practices like NN/g’s 10 Usability Heuristics.


6. Your Website Design Looks Outdated

Design impacts trust.

If your site looks like it belongs in another decade, people assume your business does too.

Red flags include:

  • Old fonts
  • Dated stock photos
  • Heavy effects (parallax from 2018…)
  • Cluttered layouts

A modern redesign instantly elevates your brand credibility.


7. Your Calls-to-Action Are Weak or Nonexistent

Your website should guide people toward a clear next step.

If your CTAs are:

  • Hidden
  • Vague
  • Weak
  • Missing

…you’re leaving real revenue on the table.

Website redesign highlighting strong CTAs and conversion paths

For ecommerce, poor CTA hierarchy kills conversions—Baymard’s checkout research shows this clearly.


8. Your CMS or Platform Is Outdated

If updating a simple headline feels like surgery, your tech stack is holding you back.

Outdated platforms lead to:

  • Security risks
  • Performance issues
  • Hard-to-edit pages
  • Plugin conflicts

A modern build on a stable platform (like WordPress + clean hosting) can fix all of that instantly. See our hosting options.


9. You’ve Disappeared From Search Results

If you’re no longer ranking on Google—even for your own brand name—your website likely has:

  • Poor structure
  • Slow load times
  • Weak content
  • Broken links
  • Outdated SEO practices

Google rewards strong UX. A website redesign improves both technical SEO and user experience, helping you regain visibility. Our SEO services pair perfectly with redesigns.


10. Your Business Has Evolved, But Your Website Hasn’t

If your site still reflects who you were years ago instead of who you are today, it’s hurting trust and conversions.

You’ve grown—your website should too.


The Bottom Line: Your Website Should Be an Asset, Not a Liability

If several of these issues sound familiar, you’re losing sales—often quietly and consistently.

A strategic website redesign can:

  • Increase conversions
  • Improve search visibility
  • Build trust
  • Strengthen branding
  • Boost revenue
  • Support long-term growth

Your website should be your hardest-working employee. If it’s dragging you down, it’s time for an upgrade.

Ready to turn your website into a revenue engine?
Let’s align your website design, local SEO, and conversion strategy.

👉 Talk to City Grove Media

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
x  Powerful Protection for WordPress, from Shield Security
This Site Is Protected By
Shield Security